twice-baked potatoes with broccoli, cheddar, and scallions


I think every food blogger recognizes that there are copyright issues with what we do. Very few of us have only original recipes on our blogs, which means the recipes we publish are from other sources – sources who would prefer that people pay money for their recipes instead of stumbling upon them in a blog.


Most of us dutifully provide the source of the recipe and then hope for the best. It’s also fairly common knowledge among bloggers that one loophole is to write out the recipe directions in our own words, because ingredient lists can’t be copyrighted. Not that this is foolproof – it’s the creative idea that is copyrighted, not the wording of the directions.


It’s not unlike birth control – the only method to guarantee that you won’t get into trouble is to abstain from blogging. If you’re not willing to do that, you take whatever precautions you’re willing to and then hope for the best.


The idea for this particular recipe comes from Cooks Illustrated. I used to make it once a month or so, since it’s easy, balanced, and fairly healthy. I hadn’t made it in over a year, but I decided not to look up the recipe. I still remembered the gist of it, and this way I could make it my own, thus avoiding the whole copyright issue. Besides, I was fairly certain that I wouldn’t be able to combine these ingredients and get anything that wasn’t good.


These are simply lightened-up twice-baked potatoes. I cut the broccoli into bite-sized florets, steamed them, and seasoned them with lemon juice and a bit of salt. Then I mashed up the baked potato innards with just enough butter to moisten them, and stirred in enough buttermilk to get the texture I was looking for – moist but not wet. Buttermilk is great with potatoes because it tastes like sour cream but isn’t nearly as fattening. I tried to be judicious with the cheese, and then scallions provided the perfect overtone of onion flavor. I stuffed the shells with the filling and put the whole thing under the broiler for a few minutes to reheat it and melt the cheese. (The final step, of course, is to drop it on the counter while transferring it from the baking sheet to a plate.)


The result is the ideal healthy-ish one-dish-meal baked potato. The shells are crispy, the broccoli is cooked just right, the potato filling is creamy, and the flavors meld perfectly. Cooks Illustrated couldn’t have done it any better.

One year ago: Country Crust Bread – my favorite sandwich bread

Twice-Baked Potatoes with Broccoli, Cheddar, and Scallions

Serves 2

This is admittedly heavy on the broccoli. You can use less if you prefer, but we like broccoli and it’s so healthy.

2 medium to large baking (russet) potatoes
2 small (or 1 large) broccoli crowns, cut into 1-inch florets with stems no longer than 1 inch
½ teaspoon lemon juice
1 tablespoon butter, softened
½ cup buttermilk
1 scallion, sliced then
1 ounce (¼ cup) cheddar, plus ½ ounce (2 tablespoons)
black pepper

1. Move an oven rack to the middle position and heat the oven to 400 degrees. Scrub the potatoes and stab them several times with a fork. Place them on the oven rack and bake until a fork inserted into the potato meets no resistance, 60-75 minutes.

2. Remove the potatoes from the oven and set them aside until they’re cool enough to handle. Heat the broiler. Meanwhile, bring 1 inch of water to a boil in a large saucepan over high heat. Place the broccoli florets in a steamer basket and put the steamer basket in the saucepan, making sure that the water does not come into contact with the broccoli. Cover the pot and steam for 4 minutes, until the broccoli is just crisp-tender. (You want it more on the crisp side, since they’ll continue to cook as they cool, plus they’ll spend some time under the broiler.) Remove the steamer basket with the broccoli from the saucepan and discard the water in the pot. Dump the broccoli into the pot and season with a pinch of salt and the lemon juice.

3. Cut the potatoes in half lengthwise. Using a spoon, scoop out the flesh of the potatoes, leaving a thin coating on the potato skin. In a medium bowl, use a potato masher to mash the potato flesh with the butter. Stir in ¼ teaspoon salt, a pinch of ground black pepper, the broccoli, plus the remaining ingredients, except ½ ounce cheddar.

4. Spoon the filling into the potato shells and top with the remaining cheddar. Place the potatoes on a baking sheet and broil until the cheese is spotty brown and the tops are crisp. Serve immediately.



  1. I agree – certain combinations of ingredients simply cannot be copyrighted. You did fine with these baked potatoes, no worries!! 🙂

  2. These look delicious! I love twice baked potatoes and this combination of ingredients sounds really good.

  3. Those look delicious! And I have seen similar recipes in Cooking Light and EatingWell. Although yours is the first that makes me actually want to try it!

  4. I do not typically like baked potatoes but these bad boys looks amazing!

  5. The beautiful photos, as always, make the recipe shine!

    I had to giggle at the “splat” potato. My mind animates it as a little potato half walking along, tripping, and falling face-first onto the “ground.”

  6. pinkstripes says:

    Yum. very delicious and healthy. Great photos!

  7. Ooh, pile on the broccoli. I like to feel healthier about it 🙂
    I am of the opinion that blog exposure is good for magazines and books (see: Baking:FMHtY) 🙂

  8. Manggy – I feel exactly the same way! I just couldn’t seem to work a sentence about it into the post. 🙂 Another good example is David Lebovitz’s The Perfect Scoop. I wouldn’t have bought it if I hadn’t heard of him from blogs.

  9. This looks so delicious and your pictures are so clean and fresh!

  10. Gorgeous photos and appreciate the addition of broccoli. Great way to introduce some greens in a fun way. You have an amazing blog, congrats.

  11. bunnies4buddha says:

    These look delicious – but I am not sure about that last step am I suppose to once drop it or twice drop it 😛

  12. great photos! looks so tasty!

  13. YUM!! I LOOOVE broccoli and cheese with potatoes!

  14. I love the broccoli and cheese! What a great meal!

  15. I love twice baked potatoes. Those look divine. I usually use fat free sour cream to make the mashed potatoes smooth.

  16. These look really yummy, Bridget!


  1. […] dinner. I really enjoyed those meals. As I was reading through my google reader I saw a post for Twice Baked Potatoes and I thought I MUST make those. I had never had twice baked potatoes before, if you can believe […]

  2. […] Twice-Baked Potatoes with Broccoli, Cheddar, and Scallions Source: The Way the Cookie Crumbles […]

  3. […] adapted from The Way the Cookie Crumbles. Photo from […]

  4. […] image source 1, source 2 , source 3, source 4 […]