banana cream pie

Dave lucked out this year when his annual birthday pie didn’t come out quite right. Because then I made another one, and then when that one wasn’t perfect either, I made another one.

The recipe is Tartine’s, and as usual, they take a classic and kick it up a notch. Their banana cream pie has the traditional flaky crust, pastry cream, bananas, and whipped cream. Then they add caramel and a thin layer of chocolate over the crust to keep the pastry cream from compromising the crust’s crispness.

The chocolate layer in my first pie was way too thick. It was like a Hershey bar on the bottom of the pie. It was impossible to cut. Dave compared it to armor. The second time, I slimmed down the chocolate, but ran out of sugar when I was making the caramel. I thought I’d come up with a way around the sugar issue, but it must not have worked because the caramel layer was hard and chewy. If the chocolate had been like leather armor over the crust, this was chain mail.

I tried one more time. And, finally! A very thin chocolate layer, the added subtleties of caramel, two layers of sliced bananas, Tartine’s wonderful light pastry cream, all topped with sweet whipped cream. Perfection. Although after my third banana cream pie in as many weeks, I am so ready for some cake or something. I’m not sure Dave agrees.

One year ago: Crispy Baked Chicken Strips
Two years ago: Moo Shu Pancakes

Printer Friendly Recipe
Banana Cream Pie (completely rewritten and slightly tweaked from Tartine’s cookbook)

Full disclosure:

1) The pastry cream pretty much always curdles for me before it boils, but I just pour it into the strainer set over a bowl, whisk like crazy and strain it, and it always ends up smooth and delicious.

2) Working with small amounts of caramel can be tricky, but I had no problems with these quantities. If you see crystals forming when the sugar mixture is bubbling, discard those ingredients and start over. If you’re worried about it working right, you might want to make twice the amount listed here and save half of it for another use.

3) I’m too lazy to set up a makeshift double boiler for 1 ounce of chocolate and I’m biased against microwaves for some reason, so I just melt the chocolate in a very small saucepan over low heat while stirring constantly.

4) The photo of the slice shows only half the whipped cream called for in the recipe, because I ran out of cream.

Pastry cream:
2 cups whole milk
¼ teaspoon salt
½ vanilla bean, cut in half and seeds scraped out
4 tablespoons cornstarch
4 ounces (½ cup + 1 tablespoon) granulated sugar
2 large eggs
4 tablespoons unsalted butter, cut into 8 cubes

5 tablespoons granulated sugar
1 tablespoon water
½ tablespoon light corn syrup
pinch salt
3 tablespoons cream
¼ teaspoon lemon juice
½ teaspoon vanilla extract
1 tablespoon butter, cut into four pieces

Whipped cream:
1 cup heavy cream, cold
2 tablespoons granulated sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla extract

1 pie crust for single-crust 9-inch pie, fully baked and cooled
1 ounce chocolate, finely chopped
3 bananas, sliced ¼-inch thick

1. For the pastry cream: Pour a bit of water into a medium saucepan and dump it out. I know it sounds strange, but wetting the bottom of the pot before adding the milk really helps keep the milk from forming a browned layer on the bottom. Add the milk, salt, and vanilla seeds to the pot and bring to a boil over medium-high heat. Meanwhile, whisk together the sugar and cornstarch in a medium bowl, then whisk in the eggs. When the milk boils, pour just a bit of it into the egg mixture, whisking constantly. Keep whisking and very gradually add the rest of the milk to the egg mixture. Pour the mixture back into the pot and whisk constantly over medium heat until the mixture thickens and just starts to boil; it will only take a few minutes (see note #1). Quickly pour the pastry cream into a fine-mesh strainer set over a medium bowl (I use the same bowl I originally mixed everything in). Use a rubber spatula to push the pastry cream through the strainer. Let the pastry cream cool for a few minutes, occasionally stirring it, and then mix in the butter, 2 cubes at a time. Press plastic wrap directly on the surface of the pastry cream and refrigerate it until completely chilled, 3-4 hours or overnight.

2. For the caramel: Pour the sugar into the center of a tall, heavy-bottomed medium saucepan (see note #2). Carefully pour the water and corn syrup over the sugar. Gently stir the mixture with a clean spatula. Place the saucepan over medium heat and bring the mixture to a boil. Before it boils, you can stir it a bit if it seems to be heating unevenly and the sugar isn’t dissolving, but once it starts to boil, stop stirring. You can gently swirl the pan if it seems to be cooking unevenly. Once the mixture becomes a light amber color, remove it from the heat and add the cream. It will bubble up a lot, so stand back. Give it a few seconds to die down, then whisk the cream into the caramel. Add the vanilla extract and lemon juice, then stir in the butter one cube at a time. Pour the caramel into a small dish.

3. Pour about an inch of water into a small saucepan and bring to a simmer (see note #3). Place the chocolate in a small heatproof bowl, place the bowl over the simmering water, and heat, stirring pretty often, until the chocolate is melted. Pour the chocolate into the cooled crust and use a pastry brush to spread it evenly. Set the chocolate aside to set for a few minutes.

4. For the whipped cream: Place the mixer bowl and whisk attachment (or beaters for a handheld mixer) in the freezer for at least 10 minutes. When the bowl is cold, add the cream and beat at high speed until soft peaks form. Add the sugar and vanilla and continue beating at high speed until firm peaks form.

5. Pour the warm-not-hot caramel over the chocolate and spread it fairly evenly. Spread half the pastry cream over the caramel, then arrange half of the banana slices over the pastry cream. Repeat with the remaining pastry cream and bananas. Spread the whipped cream over the bananas. Refrigerate the pie at least 4 hours or overnight, until set.


  1. mmm… The first pie I ever made was banana cream. Now that I think about it that was over 20 years ago. You’re looks so delicious I may have to make one 🙂

  2. Love the texture of the pie.

  3. One of my absolute favorite desserts, but this one looks better than any I’ve seen. The pastry cream looks divine and with the little bit of chocolate and caramel flavonr on top of that perfect looking pie crust?!? YUM!

  4. Hmm, I wonder if you could have warmed up the first pie. Sure, the creams would have been all over the place, but at least the chocolate wouldn’t have been armor-like 🙂
    Sigh… Been ages since I’ve had BCP. Maybe I’ll make it when I get home to Manila 🙂

  5. Wow. And Yum.

  6. I can’t believe I never had banana cream pie. This looks so delicious, and so fun to make. I should give it a try sometime.

  7. Honestly, I’ve had this thing with bananas lately. I think I ate too many as a kid (sometime before the crust of the earth hardened) and so I sort of forgot about them. For about the last two months, I’ve had a banana for a snack every afternoon around 4–and I always look forward to it. It’s been a long time since I’ve had a banana cream pie–but boy, you’ve made me want one now!

  8. Christina says:

    I love your scientific approach to find the right recipe that works best for you. Do you have a favorite pie crust recipe? I’ve never been able to make a flaky crust. Thanks

  9. bridget says:

    Christina – I used a different crust recipe for each of the pies to see if I had a preference. I’ll do a separate post eventually, but for now, I can confidently direct you to Smitten Kitchen’s recipe. I do use the food processor, but other than that, I found her simple recipe was just as good as any that I tried that included tricks for extra flakiness.

  10. Gorgeous banana cream pie. I was thinking about doing something just like this – I make a coconut cream pie with chocolate on the crust too. I think a blackbottom banana cream pie is now on order!

  11. I havwen’t had banana cream pie in ages…looks like it might be time to make one.

  12. Christina says:

    Thanks Bridget. I have used that recipe too and prebaked the shell (based on CI’s instructions) prior to filling for my pumpkin pie. However, the crust was too crispy and ended up being really thin. 🙁 Maybe I should skip the prebaking….?

  13. This pie looks fabulous – just a tad jealous you got to enjoy pastry cream and pie three times! Definitely must give this a go.

  14. I should not be reading this at 730am and wanting this for breakfast! I do want to attempt this sometime though – Can you explain in more detail how you would simplify this using instant vanilla pudding?

  15. Absolutely delicious ! Can I have a piece ?

  16. if i only have the ingredients, i will make this right away.

  17. 3 tries? That’s dedication! The pie looks delicious, banana cream pie I think is a universal favorite 🙂

  18. This looks really good and I’m trying to make it today, but I am a little confused. I don’t see any cream in the caramel ingredients list.. how much do you add?
    “Once the mixture becomes a light amber color, remove it from the heat and add the cream.”

  19. bridget says:

    Christi – Sorry about that. I added the cream to the ingredients list for the caramel.

  20. Ella black says:

    Tartine makes this pie with unsweetened whipped cream, it really offsets the sweetness of the caramel/ chocolate/ banana-ey goodness!